I like it, but you know I don't think it was the best that could've been done with that video, and I'm pretty sure if it was their input it would've been a billion times better.
yeah, there were too many locations. it was short and it was kind of fractured and didn't make a lot of sense. it's a shame. i expected a lot better. seems like a lot of work went into it without a great result.
But I still like the refreshing style of the 1D videos....no sex, no woman in underwear, no big words.... I like the idea of the old ladys in the clip.... But you are right it is a little messy...
their earlier videos were simple and that worked well. and the elaborate BSE worked but it's 6+ minutes. This is under 4 minutes & too much going on. They should have limited it to two locations or told a more coherent story (but you really can't in under 4 minutes)
i totally agree with you :) i mean it's a bit too much...all the different scenes...there's definitely too much going on!! but my favourite scene is probably the boat scene because on the boat it just looks like a normal 1D video :) they're just having fun and it doesn't look like they're acting
I like it, but you know I don't think it was the best that could've been done with that video, and I'm pretty sure if it was their input it would've been a billion times better.
ReplyDeleteyeah, there were too many locations. it was short and it was kind of fractured and didn't make a lot of sense. it's a shame. i expected a lot better. seems like a lot of work went into it without a great result.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree, we need 'a story' in their videos.. x
ReplyDeleteBut I still like the refreshing style of the 1D videos....no sex, no woman in underwear, no big words....
ReplyDeleteI like the idea of the old ladys in the clip.... But you are right it is a little messy...
their earlier videos were simple and that worked well. and the elaborate BSE worked but it's 6+ minutes. This is under 4 minutes & too much going on. They should have limited it to two locations or told a more coherent story (but you really can't in under 4 minutes)
ReplyDeletei totally agree with you :) i mean it's a bit too much...all the different scenes...there's definitely too much going on!!
Deletebut my favourite scene is probably the boat scene because on the boat it just looks like a normal 1D video :) they're just having fun and it doesn't look like they're acting
oh yes agree :) xx
Delete